Thinking Out Loud: Religious Certitude

”You know, it’s not just Calvinist who insist upon absolute certitude. The concept that God’s providence controls everything, therefore we need not doubt His “plans,” goes quite a way back. While I think this certitude in divine providence is especially true of Calvinists, it is part and parcel of evangelicalism as a whole. It not only applies to the insistence on an inerrant original text, and therefore dogmatic certitude in knowing what the Bible means, but often laps over onto discernment of God’s working in natural events, political events and history.
Case in point. While European theologians and political pundits of the day could scratch their heads about our civil war over slavery, none claimed to “know” God’s will or direction in the conflict. Yet, almost to a man, American evangelicals, on both sides of the struggle, knew pretty much exactly what God was doing. They were certain of it. God was on their side.
Flash forward to our present American culture wars, and a similar theme presents itself. Most White evangelicals “know” with complete confidence that Trump is God’s man for the hour, while “crooked Hillary” and President Obama before were not. It is interesting that so many evangelicals can claim certainty, without a doubt about the outcome of an election, about God’s providential design for America, yet fall back on mystery when questions are raised about things like slavery, ownership of women, violence in the Bible, etc.. “We’ll just have to ask Jesus when we get to heaven.” “His ways are not our ways, yada, yada.”
And then we have natural disasters. Obviously caused by the Gay Rights movement, or the removal of prayer in schools, or bakers having to cater Gay weddings…how about it’s simply a natural disaster? You see, for many evangelicals the thought that God is somehow “in control” is comforting. How that can be twisted into divine providence, for example, in something like the holocaust is beyond me. Personally, I’d rather think God had nothing to do with the holocaust and man had everything to do with it.“

See “Dear Calvinists: Try Having Mercy On Those of Us Who Doubt”
Read more at http://www.patheos.com/blogs/formerlyfundie/newsflash-calvinists-were-not-doubting-because-this-is-fun-for-us/#CkRu3tMgwAqLKR6d.99

Author: socalkdl

Like so many Evangelicals of late, I have grown weary of the so-called "Culture Wars." I can agree with Philip Yancey in his "Vanishing Grace: Whatever Happened to the Good News," that grace within the church seems to be a vanishing commodity. Although still connected to the Evangelical church I have often felt distant and removed from portions of its theology and interaction with a Post-Christian society. A few years ago I felt it necessary, for my own spiritual health, to step back and "deconstruct" my theological belief set. I had become too enmeshed in the Evangelical "bubble" to honestly and critically assess my conservative theological doctrines. What has followed in the past few years is my own journey of rediscovering the Bible, and, above all, rediscovering God. It has become a journey that still surprises and delights me. Not everything is new. The faith first delivered to me by the Evangelical church has been reaffirmed. The Good News is still the best deal out there. But there have been new discoveries as well. It is my hope that my posts encourage your own questions and reassessments. It is my conviction that, because we see through a mirror darkly, there are questions that are valid to ask, and that we should not be afraid to ask them. God bless you in your own spiritual journeys. Kirk Leavens

One thought on “Thinking Out Loud: Religious Certitude”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s